How Much Commercial Property Insurance Do I Need

 

How Much Commercial Property Insurance Do I Need?

If you own a building, lease space to tenants, or run a business with equipment and inventory, you have probably wondered:

“How much commercial property insurance do I actually need?”

You might already have a policy, but the limit on the page often feels like a guess. Maybe the number came from a lender, a quick online quote, or the amount the last owner carried. It might not have much to do with what it would really cost to rebuild and get your business back on its feet after a serious loss.

At Savon Insurance Brokerage and on savonusa.com, this is one of the most important questions business owners bring up. The concern is usually the same:

The good news is that there is a practical way to think about it. You do not need to become an actuary. You just need to understand a few key ideas:

Let us walk through it step by step, in plain English.

 

Why “How Much Commercial Property Insurance Do I Need?” Is The Right Question

It is tempting to ask a different question:

Those questions are understandable, but they are not the ones that protect you.

Guides from the Insurance Information Institute and Investopedia both point out that the primary factor in commercial property insurance is the value of your business assets, including the building. That value is what drives how much coverage you need and how much premium you pay.

If your limit is too low, you risk:

If your limit is wildly high, you might:

So “how much commercial property insurance do I need” is really about finding a realistic middle ground:

Enough coverage to rebuild and recover,
without paying for fantasy numbers or old guesses.

To do that, you need to know what the policy is actually protecting.

 

Step 1: Understand What Commercial Property Insurance Covers

Before you can answer “how much,” you have to answer “for what.”

Commercial property insurance is designed to protect the physical property your business depends on. Standard references describe three main categories in modern policies:

  1. The building
  2. Business personal property (your stuff)
  3. Property of others in your care

Let us break those down.

Building coverage

“Building” usually covers:

The ISO Building and Personal Property Coverage Form (CP 00 10) is the standard template many insurers use in the United States. It spells out these definitions and sets the rules for what counts as building.

If you own your building, you almost always need a building limit. If you are a tenant, you might still need a building related limit for:

Business personal property

Business personal property (BPP) is everything movable that belongs to the business, such as:

Commercial property guides note that policies pay claims on both your building and your business personal property when they are damaged by covered causes of loss.

If you are a tenant, this is often your main property limit. If you are an owner occupant, you need both building and BPP limits.

Property of others

Many forms also include coverage for property of others that is in your care, custody or control, up to a chosen limit.

Examples:

If that describes you, you need to think about how much of that property could realistically be on site at once, because that affects how much coverage you need.

Once you know which bucket applies to you, you can start thinking about the numbers.

 

Step 2: Focus On Replacement Cost, Not Market Price

When you ask “how much commercial property insurance do I need,” the number you are really chasing is the cost to put things back the way they were, not what you could sell them for.

Replacement cost vs market value vs tax value

These values are different things.

A commercial property blog for business owners explains three common ways to look at value:

For insurance, replacement cost is the number that matters.

Guides on property insurance limits emphasize that replacement cost value (RCV) is usually the ideal starting point for building limits, because that is what you will actually need after a serious loss.

Market value and tax value can be helpful reference points, but they are not the right answer to “how much insurance do I need.”

It is quite common for:

If you set limits based only on what you paid for the building or what the tax bill says, you risk being badly underinsured.

Replacement cost for contents

Replacement cost matters for your contents too.

For inventory and equipment, you want to think about:

Some carriers allow you to choose actual cash value (ACV) instead of replacement cost, which factors in depreciation and reduces premiums, but recent guidance explains that ACV claims are based on replacement cost minus depreciation. This usually means lower pay-outs at claim time.

For most active businesses that rely on their equipment and stock, replacement cost is usually the safer choice, even if it costs more up front.

 

Step 3: Decide What Needs Its Own Limit

To figure out how much commercial property insurance you need, you must decide which things get separate limits.

Commercial property policies usually separate limits like this:

Building limit

Your building limit should reflect:

If you are a landlord, this is usually your biggest property number.

If you are a tenant who pays for major improvements that would normally stay with the building if you moved out, you may need a separate limit for tenant improvements and betterments.

Business personal property limit

Your BPP limit should reflect:

Some businesses also carry separate limits or special coverage for high value or unique items, such as fine art, specialized tools, or expensive electronics. Those might be handled under inland marine or scheduled property, but the general idea is the same.

Property of others limit

If you hold customer property on site, you will usually see a separate limit labeled:

This limit should be based on:

By splitting things this way, you can avoid the trap of setting one guess of a limit and hoping it magically fits everything.

 

Step 4: Coinsurance And Why Underinsuring Can Hurt You

Now we come to one of the most important pieces of the puzzle: coinsurance.

Coinsurance is a clause in many commercial property policies that says:

You must insure your property for at least a certain percentage
of its total value, often 80, 90 or 100 percent.
If you do not, your claim payment can be reduced.

Several sources explain this clearly. Travelers gives an example where an 80 percent coinsurance clause requires your building limit to be at least 80 percent of its value, or claim payments are reduced in proportion to the shortfall.

Other guidance for business owners notes that coinsurance clauses typically require at least 80 percent of replacement value, and sometimes 90 or 100 percent. If you do not meet that minimum, you share more of the loss.

A simple coinsurance example

Imagine:

The insurer looks at your limit and says:

Many coinsurance clauses then apply a formula so that you only receive 62.5 percent of your claim, before the deductible.

So instead of 500,000 dollars, you might get about 312,500 dollars. You must cover the rest yourself.

This can happen even if:

Coinsurance exists to encourage everyone to insure to value. It is not a small detail. It directly affects how much insurance you need in order for your policy to work the way you expect.

 

Step 5: How To Estimate The Right Building Limit

Now that you know why underinsuring is risky, let us talk about how to pick a realistic building limit.

You do not need to draw blueprints. You just need to gather reasonable information and, ideally, get some professional help.

Start with construction details and size

To estimate replacement cost, you need basics:

Insurers and brokers use this information to run replacement cost estimators. These tools apply cost per square foot data based on location and construction type, and then adjust for features and inflation.

Savon can help you fill these in accurately so the estimate is not just a wild guess.

Use replacement cost, not what you paid

It does not matter:

What matters is what it would cost to rebuild now, including:

Articles on replacement cost for commercial buildings highlight that materials and labour costs have risen sharply in recent years, which means older valuations can become badly outdated.

If you have not updated your building limit in several years, it might be too low without you realizing it.

Consider code upgrades and unique elements

Rebuilding after a big loss means meeting current building codes, not the rules from thirty years ago.

That can mean:

Some policies include limited coverage for increased costs due to ordinance or law. Others require separate limits. You need to factor this into your building limit, especially for older structures.

If your building has unique architectural features or custom work, you may want an appraisal to support a higher value.

Update regularly

Because construction costs change, industry authors warn against relying on “old valuations” for too long. They call this the “danger of old valuations” and point out that it is a major reason insureds run into coinsurance penalties.

A good habit is to:

Savon can walk through this with you so the number keeps up with reality.

 

Step 6: How To Estimate Business Personal Property And Inventory Limits

For many businesses, the contents are just as important as the building. Here is how to think about how much coverage you need for them.

Make a simple inventory

You do not have to write a novel. Start with categories:

For each category, estimate:

Insurance valuation guides note that contents limits should be based on replacement cost, not book value or what you think you might get at a used sale.

If you use an accountant or inventory software, you can export reports and then adjust for current prices.

Plan for peak inventory, not slow season

If your stock levels change, ask yourself:

“What is the most inventory I might have here at once in a typical year?”

You want your BPP limit to be high enough to cover that peak, not just an average week. Business insurance articles warn that underinsuring stock is a common mistake for retailers and wholesalers who forget to adjust for peak season.

Remember property away from the main location

If you regularly have property:

you might need separate limits under inland marine or an off premises extension.

The total amount you might have away from the main premises should also be part of your “how much insurance do I need” calculation, especially if a large share of your assets are always on the road.

Savon can help you decide whether to:

 

Step 7: How Much Business Income Coverage You Need

Many people think of “commercial property insurance” as only the building and contents. In reality, business income and extra expense coverage is often just as important.

Regulators and insurers describe commercial insurance as protecting businesses not only from property damage, but also from business interruption that can make the difference between reopening and closing for good.

So you also need to ask:

“How much income would I lose if I had to shut down for months?”
“How long would it take me to get back to normal?”

Start with time, not dollars

First, think about time:

In many industries, a full recovery takes at least 12 months, and sometimes 18 to 24 months, depending on building type and supply chains.

Travelers and other carriers note that business income coverage is usually written with a time period, such as 12 or 18 months, and that underestimating the time to recover is a common problem.

Estimate monthly needs

Then think in monthly terms:

Business income coverage is meant to:

Your broker and accountant can help you estimate a total business income limit or pick the right time period and coinsurance percentage for business income coverage.

The key idea:

The more dependent you are on this specific location and equipment,
the more important it is to carry enough business income coverage.

 

Step 8: Deductibles, Sub limits And Other Numbers That Affect “How Much”

“How much commercial property insurance do I need” is not only about limits. It is also about:

Deductibles

Higher deductibles mean:

You should choose a deductible that:

If a large loss would be the real disaster, you may prefer to keep a reasonable deductible and focus on having strong limits and business income coverage.

Sub limits

Many policies have sub limits for certain things, such as:

These are often small by default. If any of these matter a lot to your business, you may need to raise those sub limits or add endorsements.

Coverage overviews explain that limits for specific categories are usually listed separately in the declarations or coverage form, and they can be lower than your main building or BPP limit.

Coverage form choice

If you want your limits to work the way you expect, you also need to know if you have:

Special form with replacement cost is usually more protective, but it costs more. Basic or Broad form with ACV will have lower premiums and lower claim pay-outs.

Savon can help you see how these choices affect not just “how much” insurance you have, but how well it performs in real situations.

 

Special Situations That Change How Much Coverage You Need

Not every building is a simple, single owner, single occupant situation. Some setups change how much insurance you need and how you think about limits.

Owner occupied building with a lender

If you own the building and also use it, your commercial property limit needs to satisfy:

State and lender guides note that commercial lenders usually require borrowers to carry property insurance that protects the building used as collateral, and to keep a certain level of coverage in place for the life of the loan.

In practice:

Savon can help you line up your coverage with both your risk and your lender’s conditions.

Landlord with multiple tenants

If you lease space to multiple tenants, your building limit needs to reflect:

At the same time:

You may also need different limits or sub limit if you have:

Commercial property guides explain that you can either schedule buildings separately with individual limits or use a blanket limit that applies across multiple buildings, as long as total values are accurate.

Condo or association situations

If your property is part of a commercial condo or association:

Association documents will spell out who is responsible for:

You then set your own building or improvements limit to match that responsibility.

 

Common Mistakes People Make When Choosing Limits

Knowing what not to do can be as helpful as knowing what to do. Here are some frequent errors that lead to painful surprises.

Using purchase price or tax value as the limit

As we saw earlier, purchase price and assessed value often have little to do with current replacement cost. Articles on property insurance limits warn that relying on these numbers is a major source of underinsurance.

Letting limits sit for years without review

Construction costs, labour rates and code requirements change. If you set a limit five or ten years ago and never updated it, there is a good chance it is now too low.

Specialists in commercial property caution that “old valuations” are a serious risk, especially in a high inflation environment.

Ignoring coinsurance

Many policyholders do not realize they have a coinsurance clause until they have a claim. That is a bad time to discover that you were required to insure 80 or 90 percent of value.

Consumer and state insurance guides emphasize that coinsurance clauses can reduce claim payments if you do not meet the minimum percentage of value.

Forgetting tenant improvements

Tenants often spend real money on build outs, such as:

If your lease makes you responsible for those improvements, you need to include them in your building or improvements limit. If not, you may not have enough coverage to put your space back the way you need it.

Leaving out business income

Many owners think “property” and forget about income. Then a major loss happens and they realize that fixing the building does not pay their employees or their rent during months of downtime.

Regulators and insurers repeatedly stress that business interruption coverage is one of the most important parts of a commercial insurance program, not an optional extra.

 

A Simple Framework To Answer “How Much Commercial Property Insurance Do I Need?”

Let us bring this all together into a simple checklist you can use with Savon or your current broker.

  1. List what you need to insure

  1. Estimate realistic replacement costs

For each category:

ask:

“What would it cost to rebuild or replace this today, with similar quality and features?”

Use:

  1. Check coinsurance requirements

Look at your policy (or proposed policy) to see:

Make sure your limits meet or exceed those percentages based on your value estimates. If they do not, you risk penalties.

  1. Decide on valuation and deductibles

Choose:

These choices affect your premium, but they also change how your limits perform at claim time.

  1. Address income, not just property

Decide:

Then choose a business income limit and coverage period that matches that reality.

  1. Review regularly

Set a reminder to:

With that framework, “how much commercial property insurance do I need” becomes a series of clear, concrete decisions instead of one fuzzy guess.

 

How Savon Insurance Brokerage Helps You Get The Numbers Right

You do not have to figure all of this out on your own.

Savon Insurance Brokerage is a virtual independent brokerage, which means:

Their online presence highlights that they help clients compare multiple insurance company offers so you get a better match for your needs instead of a one size fits all policy.

For a question like “how much commercial property insurance do I need,” Savon can:

Instead of guessing at a limit and hoping it is enough, you get a clear, reasoned approach to protecting the property and income your business depends on.

 

Final Thoughts: Enough To Rebuild, Enough To Breathe

When you strip away the jargon, “how much commercial property insurance do I need” comes down to this:

That means:

With the right guidance from a broker like Savon Insurance Brokerage, commercial property insurance turns from a confusing bill into a clear safety net that fits your real world risk.

You worked hard to build your business. Having the right amount of commercial property insurance is simply the way you make sure one fire, storm or break in is a setback, not the end of the story.

Tagged

Copyright © 2025 Savon Insurance Brokerage All Rights Reserved.